The Curiosity Gap: When Expertise Starts Replacing Inquiry
The more we think we know, the less we may think to ask.
I was having a conversation with a senior leader who was frustrated that their team wasn't demonstrating the level of ownership they wanted to see. They wanted people to take more initiative, make decisions and contribute more meaningfully. They had a pretty clear picture of what wasn't happening and what they believed needed to change.
As we explored the situation, I asked a question that shifted the direction of our conversation. How well do you actually know these people? Not their job descriptions, performance results or responsibilities, but what motivates them, what matters to them, what they aspire to and what might be getting in their way.
It's a question I find myself coming back to often in my coaching work. Because sometimes the challenge isn't that leaders don't know enough about the business. It's that they don't know enough about the people they're leading.
When experience becomes an assumption
Experience is an incredible asset in leadership. It helps us recognize patterns, anticipate challenges and make decisions with greater perspective. But it can also create blind spots.
The longer we've been doing something, the easier it becomes to believe we understand what's happening around us. We think we know why someone isn't contributing, why a team member is resistant to change, why someone isn't stepping forward or why a particular approach isn't working. And once we believe we understand the problem, we naturally begin looking for solutions.
The trouble is that our interpretation isn't always the full story.
A team member who seems disengaged may be uncertain about what's expected of them. Someone who isn't speaking up may have learned through experience that their ideas aren't welcome. A person who appears resistant may see a risk or possibility we haven't considered. Without curiosity, we may never discover the difference.
The gap between what we intend and what others experience
I often talk about the gap between our intentions and how others experience us. A leader may genuinely believe they're approachable, supportive and interested in hearing different perspectives. Yet the people around them may experience something quite different.
Perhaps the leader responds to ideas by immediately explaining why they won't work. Perhaps they ask for input but consistently make the decision before anyone has had an opportunity to contribute. Or perhaps they're so quick to solve problems that their people stop bringing their own thinking to the conversation.
None of these behaviours necessarily comes from a lack of care. But intention alone doesn't determine impact. Curiosity gives us an opportunity to understand how our behaviour is being experienced, rather than assuming others see what we intend.
Curiosity is more than asking questions
I don't believe being curious means simply asking more questions. It's about being genuinely interested in discovering something you don't already know.
There's a difference between asking a question because you're waiting for someone to arrive at your answer and asking because you're open to learning something that might change your thinking. People can often feel that difference.
And when leaders demonstrate genuine curiosity, they create opportunities for others to think more deeply, challenge assumptions and contribute perspectives that might otherwise remain unheard. This is particularly important when we're trying to develop future leaders. If every conversation ends with our answer, we're not necessarily developing someone else's ability to think. We're teaching them to rely on ours.
Making room for a different perspective
One of the things I love most about coaching is the opportunity to challenge what someone believes to be true. Not because their thinking is necessarily wrong, but because there's often more to discover.
I might hear a leader describe someone as difficult, unmotivated or unwilling to take ownership. Rather than immediately exploring what to do about that person, I'm interested in understanding how the leader arrived at that conclusion. What have they observed? What have they assumed? What conversations have they had? What might they not yet understand?
Very often, exploring those questions creates possibilities that weren't visible when we were focused solely on solving the original problem. And that same approach can be incredibly powerful in everyday leadership.
Closing the Curiosity Gap
The Curiosity Gap isn't about having less expertise or becoming less decisive. It's about recognizing that our experience, while valuable, doesn't give us access to everything happening in someone else's world.
Sometimes leadership requires us to hold our assumptions a little more loosely and make room for another perspective. The next time you find yourself frustrated by someone's behaviour, disappointed by a lack of ownership or convinced you already understand the problem, consider asking yourself:
What might I discover if I became more curious about this person than certain about my interpretation of them?
Because sometimes the most valuable thing we can bring to a leadership conversation isn't a better answer. It's a question that helps everyone see something differently.
Explore more of The Leadership Gaps, including the Identity Gap and Explicitness Gap, and how they influence leadership effectiveness.
Jacqueline "Jax" Rose, PCC | Executive & Leadership Coach