The Identity Gap: When Being Involved Feels Like Leadership
When the skills that made you successful start getting in the way of leading.
One of the most interesting transitions in leadership happens when the very things that made someone successful begin to get in the way of their ability to lead.
Think about it. Most people are promoted into leadership because they're good at something. They have experience, expertise, strong problem-solving skills and a proven ability to get things done. They're often the person everyone turns to when something needs to be figured out. Then they become responsible for leading other people, and suddenly the way they have always created value needs to change. That isn't necessarily an easy transition.
When being helpful becomes a barrier
I see this frequently in my coaching conversations. Leaders who genuinely want their people to grow, take ownership and become more independent, yet find themselves continually stepping back into the work. They answer questions before their team has had an opportunity to think. They take over when something isn't moving quickly enough. They get involved in decisions that others are perfectly capable of making.
Often, their intentions are good. They want to help, they care about the outcome and they believe their involvement is making things easier for everyone. And sometimes it is. But there's a difference between making someone's work easier and helping them become more capable of doing it.
When a leader is consistently the person providing the answers, making the decisions or solving the problems, they may unintentionally be creating the very dependency they wish their team would move beyond.
The identity we've built around being good at what we do
I think this is where the deeper challenge sits.
For years, our professional identity is shaped by what we contribute. We're recognized for our expertise, our ability to solve problems and the results we personally deliver. Those experiences reinforce our sense of value. So what happens when leadership asks us to step away from those things?
If I'm not the person solving the problem, how am I adding value? If someone else can do this without me, what exactly is my role?
These aren't always questions leaders consciously ask themselves, but I believe they influence more leadership behaviour than we realize. Letting go of the work can feel a little like letting go of the identity that helped us get here.
Learning to lead differently
I experienced this shift in my own leadership career. After years of working in hospitality, sales and leadership, I found myself leading people who were far more technically proficient in certain areas than I was. I wasn't going to be the person with all the answers, and trying to become that person wouldn't have been the best use of my time or theirs.
Instead, I focused on understanding what my people needed to be successful. I asked questions, helped remove obstacles, created opportunities and encouraged them to use their own expertise. I learned that my greatest contribution wasn't necessarily what I could accomplish myself, but what I could make possible through other people.
That experience has stayed with me throughout my coaching career.
From being the player to becoming the coach
One of the ways I like to think about this transition is moving from being the player to becoming the coach.
As a player, you're focused on your own performance. Your expertise, your decisions and your actions directly influence the result. As a coach, your success depends increasingly on your ability to help others perform.
You still bring experience and expertise. You still have a responsibility to provide direction, make decisions and hold people accountable. But you become more intentional about when your involvement adds value and when it might actually be getting in the way.
Instead of immediately offering a solution, you might ask someone how they're thinking about the problem. Instead of taking something over, you might help them identify what they need to move forward. Instead of measuring your contribution by how much you're doing, you begin to notice how much more others are capable of doing.
And the interesting part is that as your people become more capable, so do you. You create the capacity to focus on the things that truly require your leadership.
Recognizing the Identity Gap
The Identity Gap doesn't mean you've lost the skills that made you successful. It means your leadership is asking you to use them differently.
Sometimes the greatest opportunity for growth isn't learning how to do more. It's becoming comfortable with the idea that your value no longer needs to be demonstrated through your direct involvement in everything.
For leaders who recognize themselves in this, I would encourage you to reflect on one question:
Where might your need to contribute be limiting someone else's opportunity to grow?
Because the next stage of your leadership may have less to do with what you can accomplish and more to do with what you can help others become.
Explore more of The Leadership Gaps, including how the Self-Trust Gap and Curiosity Gap can influence the way we lead and develop others.
Jacqueline "Jax" Rose, PCC | Executive & Leadership Coach